// Numbas version: finer_feedback_settings {"name": "Creep Curve #1 w/ units", "extensions": ["quantities"], "custom_part_types": [{"source": {"pk": 19, "author": {"name": "William Haynes", "pk": 2530}, "edit_page": "/part_type/19/edit"}, "name": "Engineering Accuracy with units", "short_name": "engineering-answer", "description": "

A value with units marked right if within an adjustable % error of the correct value.  Marked close if within a wider margin of error.

", "help_url": "", "input_widget": "string", "input_options": {"correctAnswer": "siground(settings['correctAnswer'],4)", "hint": {"static": true, "value": ""}, "allowEmpty": {"static": true, "value": true}}, "can_be_gap": true, "can_be_step": true, "marking_script": "mark:\nswitch( \n right and good_units and right_sign, add_credit(1.0,'Correct.'),\n right and good_units and not right_sign, add_credit(settings['C2'],'Wrong sign.'),\n right and right_sign and not good_units, add_credit(settings['C2'],'Correct value, but wrong or missing units.'),\n close and good_units, add_credit(settings['C1'],'Close.'),\n close and not good_units, add_credit(settings['C3'],'Answer is close, but wrong or missing units.'),\n incorrect('Wrong answer.')\n)\n\ninterpreted_answer:\nqty(student_scalar, student_units)\n\n\n\ncorrect_quantity:\nsettings[\"correctAnswer\"]\n\n\n\ncorrect_units:\nunits(correct_quantity)\n\n\nallowed_notation_styles:\n[\"plain\",\"en\"]\n\nmatch_student_number:\nmatchnumber(studentAnswer,allowed_notation_styles)\n\nstudent_scalar:\nmatch_student_number[1]\n\nstudent_units:\nreplace_regex('ohms','ohm',\n replace_regex('\u00b0', ' deg',\n replace_regex('-', ' ' ,\n studentAnswer[len(match_student_number[0])..len(studentAnswer)])),\"i\")\n\ngood_units:\ntry(\ncompatible(quantity(1, student_units),correct_units),\nmsg,\nfeedback(msg);false)\n\n\nstudent_quantity:\nswitch(not good_units, \n student_scalar * correct_units, \n not right_sign,\n -quantity(student_scalar, student_units),\n quantity(student_scalar,student_units)\n)\n \n\n\npercent_error:\ntry(\nscalar(abs((correct_quantity - student_quantity)/correct_quantity))*100 \n,msg,\nif(student_quantity=correct_quantity,0,100))\n \n\nright:\npercent_error <= settings['right']\n\n\nclose:\nright_sign and percent_error <= settings['close']\n\nright_sign:\nsign(student_scalar) = sign(correct_quantity)", "marking_notes": [{"name": "mark", "description": "This is the main marking note. It should award credit and provide feedback based on the student's answer.", "definition": "switch( \n right and good_units and right_sign, add_credit(1.0,'Correct.'),\n right and good_units and not right_sign, add_credit(settings['C2'],'Wrong sign.'),\n right and right_sign and not good_units, add_credit(settings['C2'],'Correct value, but wrong or missing units.'),\n close and good_units, add_credit(settings['C1'],'Close.'),\n close and not good_units, add_credit(settings['C3'],'Answer is close, but wrong or missing units.'),\n incorrect('Wrong answer.')\n)"}, {"name": "interpreted_answer", "description": "A value representing the student's answer to this part.", "definition": "qty(student_scalar, student_units)\n\n"}, {"name": "correct_quantity", "description": "", "definition": "settings[\"correctAnswer\"]\n\n"}, {"name": "correct_units", "description": "", "definition": "units(correct_quantity)\n"}, {"name": "allowed_notation_styles", "description": "", "definition": "[\"plain\",\"en\"]"}, {"name": "match_student_number", "description": "", "definition": "matchnumber(studentAnswer,allowed_notation_styles)"}, {"name": "student_scalar", "description": "", "definition": "match_student_number[1]"}, {"name": "student_units", "description": "

Modify the unit portion of the student's answer by

\n

1. replacing \"ohms\" with \"ohm\"  case insensitive

\n

2. replacing '-' with ' ' 

\n

3. replacing '°' with ' deg' 

\n

to allow answers like 10 ft-lb and 30°

", "definition": "replace_regex('ohms','ohm',\n replace_regex('\u00b0', ' deg',\n replace_regex('-', ' ' ,\n studentAnswer[len(match_student_number[0])..len(studentAnswer)])),\"i\")"}, {"name": "good_units", "description": "", "definition": "try(\ncompatible(quantity(1, student_units),correct_units),\nmsg,\nfeedback(msg);false)\n"}, {"name": "student_quantity", "description": "

This fixes the student answer for two common errors.  

\n

If student_units are wrong  - replace with correct units

\n

If student_scalar has the wrong sign - replace with right sign

\n

If student makes both errors, only one gets fixed.

", "definition": "switch(not good_units, \n student_scalar * correct_units, \n not right_sign,\n -quantity(student_scalar, student_units),\n quantity(student_scalar,student_units)\n)\n \n"}, {"name": "percent_error", "description": "", "definition": "try(\nscalar(abs((correct_quantity - student_quantity)/correct_quantity))*100 \n,msg,\nif(student_quantity=correct_quantity,0,100))\n "}, {"name": "right", "description": "", "definition": "percent_error <= settings['right']\n"}, {"name": "close", "description": "

Only marked close if the student actually has the right sign.

", "definition": "right_sign and percent_error <= settings['close']"}, {"name": "right_sign", "description": "", "definition": "sign(student_scalar) = sign(correct_quantity) "}], "settings": [{"name": "correctAnswer", "label": "Correct Quantity.", "help_url": "", "hint": "The correct answer given as a JME quantity.", "input_type": "code", "default_value": "", "evaluate": true}, {"name": "right", "label": "% Accuracy for right.", "help_url": "", "hint": "Question will be considered correct if the scalar part of the student's answer is within this % of correct value.", "input_type": "code", "default_value": "0.2", "evaluate": true}, {"name": "close", "label": "% Accuracy for close.", "help_url": "", "hint": "Question will be considered close if the scalar part of the student's answer is within this % of correct value.", "input_type": "code", "default_value": "1.0", "evaluate": true}, {"name": "C1", "label": "Close with units.", "help_url": "", "hint": "Partial Credit for close value with appropriate units.  if correct answer is 100 N and close is ±1%,
99  N is accepted.", "input_type": "percent", "default_value": "75"}, {"name": "C2", "label": "No units or wrong sign", "help_url": "", "hint": "Partial credit for forgetting units or using wrong sign.
If the correct answer is 100 N, both 100 and -100 N are accepted.", "input_type": "percent", "default_value": "50"}, {"name": "C3", "label": "Close, no units.", "help_url": "", "hint": "Partial Credit for close value but forgotten units.
This value would be close if the expected units were provided.  If the correct answer is 100 N, and close is ±1%,
99 is accepted.", "input_type": "percent", "default_value": "25"}], "public_availability": "always", "published": true, "extensions": ["quantities"]}], "resources": [["question-resources/CreepCurve.png", "28f90168a76533c42724ba59431bef5a8cf2018de685890c79c61bd8505db459.png"]], "navigation": {"allowregen": true, "showfrontpage": false, "preventleave": false, "typeendtoleave": false}, "feedback": {"showactualmarkwhen": "always", "showtotalmarkwhen": "always", "showanswerstatewhen": "always", "showpartfeedbackmessageswhen": "always", "allowrevealanswer": true, "showexpectedanswerswhen": "inreview", "showadvicewhen": "inreview"}, "question_groups": [{"pickingStrategy": "all-ordered", "questions": [{"name": "Creep Curve #1 w/ units", "tags": [], "metadata": {"description": "Maximising locomotive traction by controlling wheel speed.
", "licence": "Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International"}, "statement": "

Introductions to friction usually show a rectangular block in contact with a flat plane and distinguish between the coefficient of static friction (when the block is stationary) and the coefficient of kinetic friction (when the block is moving at constant speed); the coefficient of friction is usually regarded as being independent of the applied normal load and the sliding speed.

\n

In rolling contact, between moving train wheel and static rail, the surfaces in contact may be static relative to each other ('no slip') or sliding against each other ('slip'). In normal operation, whenever traction is applied (whether accelerating or braking), the wheel-rail contact has a mixture of regions of slip and no-slip. The extremes of this are 'pure rolling', where there is no traction (and no torque applied to or by the wheel) and no slip; and 'full slip', where the contact is fully slipping and the available traction limited by the kinetic friction. Full slip can also be damaging to both wheel and rail, because high local temperatures affect the steel microstructure.

\n

The complex nature of wheel-rail contact makes the apparent friction coefficient dependent on the amount of slip between the wheel and rail. One way to characterise the slip is through creepage, $\\gamma$:

\n

$\\gamma = {\\text{Difference in speed} \\over \\text{Average speed}} = 2 {\\omega R - v_\\text{train} \\over \\omega R + v_\\text{train}}$

\n

where $\\omega$ and $R$ are the angular velocity [units: rad/s] and radius of the train wheels. The relationship between friction coefficient and creepage is usually similar to that shown below. To maximise the available traction, locomotive drive systems seek to maintain a creepage that maximises the friction coefficient.

\n

", "advice": "

A locomotive seeks to optimise traction using the approximate creep curve:

\n

$\\mu = (a + b\\gamma)e^{-\\gamma/c}$

\n

where $a=\\var{a}$, $b=\\var{b}$ and $c=\\var{c}$. The locomotive has six axles, all powered, and the axle load is $\\var{axle_load}$ tonnes. The wheel diameter is $\\var{diameter}$m.

\n

Gravitational acceleration is $g = 9.81$ m/s$^2$.

\n

To find the maximum friction coefficient and the corresponding creepage, take the derivative and set it to zero:

\n

$0 = {d \\mu \\over d \\gamma} = (b)e^{-\\gamma/c} - {(a + b\\gamma) \\over c}e^{-\\gamma/c} \\implies bc = a + b\\gamma$

\n
    \n
  1. The creepage corresponding to the maximum friction is $(bc-a)/b=(\\var{b} \\times \\var{c}-\\var{a})/\\var{b}=\\var{x0}=\\var{max_creep}$% [Expressed as percentage.]
  2. \n
  3. The maximum coefficient of friction, by substituting $\\gamma=\\var{x0}$ into the creep curve, is: $\\var{siground(max_fric,3)}$
  4. \n
  5. The maximum available traction is the maximum friction coefficient times the weight of the loco, i.e., six axles $\\times \\ \\var{axle_load}$ tonnes $\\times \\ 9.81 \\times \\var{siground(max_fric,3)} = \\var{siground(max_trac,3)}$ [units: kN]
  6. \n
  7. If $W$ [r.p.m.] is the angular velocity of the wheels in revolutions per minute, and $V$ [km/h] is the velocity of the train in kilometres per hour, then to sustain maximum available traction the ratio $W/V$ must be:
  8. \n
\n

The definition of creepage can be rearranged to give angular wheel velocity $\\omega$ [rad/s] in terms of train velocity $v$ [m/s]:

\n

$\\gamma = 2 {\\omega D/2 - v \\over \\omega D/2 + v} \\implies \\gamma (\\omega D/2 + v) = 2 (\\omega D/2 - v) \\implies (2 - \\gamma) \\omega D/2 = (2 + \\gamma) v$

\n

In standard units, therefore:

\n

$\\omega = {(2 + \\gamma) \\over (2 - \\gamma)} {v \\over D/2}$

\n

The question asks for $W$ [r.p.m.] and $V$ [km/h], so:

\n

$W = \\omega \\times {60 \\over 2 \\pi} = {60 \\over 2 \\pi}{(2 + \\gamma) \\over (2 - \\gamma)} {v \\over D/2} = {60 \\over 2 \\pi}{(2 + \\gamma) \\over (2 - \\gamma)} {V / 3.6 \\over D/2}$

\n

Finally, therefore:

\n

${W \\over V} = {60 \\over 2 \\pi}{(2 + \\gamma) \\over (2 - \\gamma)} {1 / 3.6 \\over D/2} = {60 \\over 2 \\pi}{(2 + \\var{x0}) \\over (2 - \\var{x0})} {1 / 3.6 \\over \\var{diameter}/2} = \\var{siground(WV_ratio,3)}$

", "rulesets": {}, "extensions": [], "builtin_constants": {"e": true, "pi,\u03c0": true, "i": true, "j": false}, "constants": [], "variables": {"x0": {"name": "x0", "group": "Ungrouped variables", "definition": "random(1..5)/100", "description": "

Maximum creepage.

", "templateType": "anything", "can_override": false}, "a": {"name": "a", "group": "Ungrouped variables", "definition": "random(1..3)/10", "description": "

Creep curve constant.

", "templateType": "anything", "can_override": false}, "b": {"name": "b", "group": "Ungrouped variables", "definition": "random(4..5)*5", "description": "

Creep curve constant.

", "templateType": "anything", "can_override": false}, "c": {"name": "c", "group": "Ungrouped variables", "definition": "x0+a/b", "description": "

Creep curve constant.

", "templateType": "anything", "can_override": false}, "max_creep": {"name": "max_creep", "group": "Ungrouped variables", "definition": "x0*100", "description": "

Creepage at maximum friction [%].

", "templateType": "anything", "can_override": false}, "max_fric": {"name": "max_fric", "group": "Ungrouped variables", "definition": "(a+b*x0)*exp(-x0/c)", "description": "

Maximum friction coefficient.

", "templateType": "anything", "can_override": false}, "axle_load": {"name": "axle_load", "group": "Ungrouped variables", "definition": "random(8..20)*2.5", "description": "

Axle load [tonnes].

", "templateType": "anything", "can_override": false}, "max_trac": {"name": "max_trac", "group": "Ungrouped variables", "definition": "axle_load*9.81*6*max_fric", "description": "

Maximum available traction [kN].

", "templateType": "anything", "can_override": false}, "WV_ratio": {"name": "WV_ratio", "group": "Ungrouped variables", "definition": "((((2 + x0) / (2 - x0)) / 3.6) / (diameter/2)) * 60 / (2 * pi)", "description": "

Ratio of wheel angular velocity [r.p.m.] to vehicle speed [km/h] for maximum available traction.

", "templateType": "anything", "can_override": false}, "diameter": {"name": "diameter", "group": "Ungrouped variables", "definition": "random(8..12)/10", "description": "

Wheel diameter [m].

", "templateType": "anything", "can_override": false}}, "variablesTest": {"condition": "", "maxRuns": 100}, "ungrouped_variables": ["x0", "a", "b", "c", "axle_load", "max_creep", "max_fric", "max_trac", "diameter", "WV_ratio"], "variable_groups": [], "functions": {}, "preamble": {"js": "", "css": ""}, "parts": [{"type": "gapfill", "useCustomName": true, "customName": "Locomotive", "marks": 0, "scripts": {}, "customMarkingAlgorithm": "", "extendBaseMarkingAlgorithm": true, "unitTests": [], "showCorrectAnswer": true, "showFeedbackIcon": true, "variableReplacements": [], "variableReplacementStrategy": "originalfirst", "nextParts": [], "suggestGoingBack": false, "adaptiveMarkingPenalty": 0, "exploreObjective": null, "prompt": "

A locomotive seeks to optimise traction using the approximate creep curve:

\n

$\\mu = (a + bx)e^{-x/c}$

\n

where $a=\\var{a}$, $b=\\var{b}$ and $c=\\var{c}$. The locomotive has six axles, all powered, and the axle load is $\\var{axle_load}$ tonnes. The wheel diameter is $\\var{diameter}$m.

\n

Gravitational acceleration is $g = 9.81$ m/s$^2$.

\n
    \n
  1. The creepage corresponding to the maximum friction is: [[0]]% [Expressed as percentage.]
  2. \n
  3. The maximum coefficient of friction is: [[1]]
  4. \n
  5. The maximum available traction is: [[2]]
  6. \n
  7. If $W$ [r.p.m.] is the angular velocity of the wheels in revolutions per minute, and $V$ [km/h] is the velocity of the train in kilometres per hour, then to sustain maximum available traction the ratio $W/V$ must be: [[3]]
  8. \n
", "gaps": [{"type": "engineering-answer", "useCustomName": true, "customName": "Max: Creepage", "marks": "2", "scripts": {}, "customMarkingAlgorithm": "", "extendBaseMarkingAlgorithm": true, "unitTests": [], "showCorrectAnswer": true, "showFeedbackIcon": true, "variableReplacements": [], "variableReplacementStrategy": "originalfirst", "nextParts": [], "suggestGoingBack": false, "adaptiveMarkingPenalty": 0, "exploreObjective": null, "settings": {"correctAnswer": "quantity(max_creep,\"\")", "right": "0.2", "close": "1.0", "C1": "75", "C2": "50", "C3": "25"}}, {"type": "engineering-answer", "useCustomName": true, "customName": "Max: Friction", "marks": "2", "scripts": {}, "customMarkingAlgorithm": "", "extendBaseMarkingAlgorithm": true, "unitTests": [], "showCorrectAnswer": true, "showFeedbackIcon": true, "variableReplacements": [], "variableReplacementStrategy": "originalfirst", "nextParts": [], "suggestGoingBack": false, "adaptiveMarkingPenalty": 0, "exploreObjective": null, "settings": {"correctAnswer": "quantity(max_fric,\"\")", "right": "0.2", "close": "1.0", "C1": "75", "C2": "50", "C3": "25"}}, {"type": "engineering-answer", "useCustomName": true, "customName": "Max: Traction", "marks": "2", "scripts": {}, "customMarkingAlgorithm": "", "extendBaseMarkingAlgorithm": true, "unitTests": [], "showCorrectAnswer": true, "showFeedbackIcon": true, "variableReplacements": [], "variableReplacementStrategy": "originalfirst", "nextParts": [], "suggestGoingBack": false, "adaptiveMarkingPenalty": 0, "exploreObjective": null, "settings": {"correctAnswer": "quantity(max_trac*1000,\"N\")", "right": "0.2", "close": "1.0", "C1": "75", "C2": "50", "C3": "25"}}, {"type": "engineering-answer", "useCustomName": true, "customName": "W/V", "marks": "4", "scripts": {}, "customMarkingAlgorithm": "", "extendBaseMarkingAlgorithm": true, "unitTests": [], "showCorrectAnswer": true, "showFeedbackIcon": true, "variableReplacements": [], "variableReplacementStrategy": "originalfirst", "nextParts": [], "suggestGoingBack": false, "adaptiveMarkingPenalty": 0, "exploreObjective": null, "settings": {"correctAnswer": "quantity(WV_ratio,\"\")", "right": "0.2", "close": "1.0", "C1": "75", "C2": "50", "C3": "25"}}], "sortAnswers": false}], "partsMode": "all", "maxMarks": 0, "objectives": [], "penalties": [], "objectiveVisibility": "always", "penaltyVisibility": "always", "contributors": [{"name": "Francis Franklin", "profile_url": "https://numbas.mathcentre.ac.uk/accounts/profile/1887/"}], "resources": ["question-resources/CreepCurve.png"]}]}], "contributors": [{"name": "Francis Franklin", "profile_url": "https://numbas.mathcentre.ac.uk/accounts/profile/1887/"}]}