// Numbas version: finer_feedback_settings {"name": "Hunting #1 w/ units", "extensions": ["quantities"], "custom_part_types": [{"source": {"pk": 19, "author": {"name": "William Haynes", "pk": 2530}, "edit_page": "/part_type/19/edit"}, "name": "Engineering Accuracy with units", "short_name": "engineering-answer", "description": "

A value with units marked right if within an adjustable % error of the correct value.  Marked close if within a wider margin of error.

", "help_url": "", "input_widget": "string", "input_options": {"correctAnswer": "siground(settings['correctAnswer'],4)", "hint": {"static": true, "value": ""}, "allowEmpty": {"static": true, "value": true}}, "can_be_gap": true, "can_be_step": true, "marking_script": "mark:\nswitch( \n right and good_units and right_sign, add_credit(1.0,'Correct.'),\n right and good_units and not right_sign, add_credit(settings['C2'],'Wrong sign.'),\n right and right_sign and not good_units, add_credit(settings['C2'],'Correct value, but wrong or missing units.'),\n close and good_units, add_credit(settings['C1'],'Close.'),\n close and not good_units, add_credit(settings['C3'],'Answer is close, but wrong or missing units.'),\n incorrect('Wrong answer.')\n)\n\ninterpreted_answer:\nqty(student_scalar, student_units)\n\n\n\ncorrect_quantity:\nsettings[\"correctAnswer\"]\n\n\n\ncorrect_units:\nunits(correct_quantity)\n\n\nallowed_notation_styles:\n[\"plain\",\"en\"]\n\nmatch_student_number:\nmatchnumber(studentAnswer,allowed_notation_styles)\n\nstudent_scalar:\nmatch_student_number[1]\n\nstudent_units:\nreplace_regex('ohms','ohm',\n replace_regex('\u00b0', ' deg',\n replace_regex('-', ' ' ,\n studentAnswer[len(match_student_number[0])..len(studentAnswer)])),\"i\")\n\ngood_units:\ntry(\ncompatible(quantity(1, student_units),correct_units),\nmsg,\nfeedback(msg);false)\n\n\nstudent_quantity:\nswitch(not good_units, \n student_scalar * correct_units, \n not right_sign,\n -quantity(student_scalar, student_units),\n quantity(student_scalar,student_units)\n)\n \n\n\npercent_error:\ntry(\nscalar(abs((correct_quantity - student_quantity)/correct_quantity))*100 \n,msg,\nif(student_quantity=correct_quantity,0,100))\n \n\nright:\npercent_error <= settings['right']\n\n\nclose:\nright_sign and percent_error <= settings['close']\n\nright_sign:\nsign(student_scalar) = sign(correct_quantity)", "marking_notes": [{"name": "mark", "description": "This is the main marking note. It should award credit and provide feedback based on the student's answer.", "definition": "switch( \n right and good_units and right_sign, add_credit(1.0,'Correct.'),\n right and good_units and not right_sign, add_credit(settings['C2'],'Wrong sign.'),\n right and right_sign and not good_units, add_credit(settings['C2'],'Correct value, but wrong or missing units.'),\n close and good_units, add_credit(settings['C1'],'Close.'),\n close and not good_units, add_credit(settings['C3'],'Answer is close, but wrong or missing units.'),\n incorrect('Wrong answer.')\n)"}, {"name": "interpreted_answer", "description": "A value representing the student's answer to this part.", "definition": "qty(student_scalar, student_units)\n\n"}, {"name": "correct_quantity", "description": "", "definition": "settings[\"correctAnswer\"]\n\n"}, {"name": "correct_units", "description": "", "definition": "units(correct_quantity)\n"}, {"name": "allowed_notation_styles", "description": "", "definition": "[\"plain\",\"en\"]"}, {"name": "match_student_number", "description": "", "definition": "matchnumber(studentAnswer,allowed_notation_styles)"}, {"name": "student_scalar", "description": "", "definition": "match_student_number[1]"}, {"name": "student_units", "description": "

Modify the unit portion of the student's answer by

\n

1. replacing \"ohms\" with \"ohm\"  case insensitive

\n

2. replacing '-' with ' ' 

\n

3. replacing '°' with ' deg' 

\n

to allow answers like 10 ft-lb and 30°

", "definition": "replace_regex('ohms','ohm',\n replace_regex('\u00b0', ' deg',\n replace_regex('-', ' ' ,\n studentAnswer[len(match_student_number[0])..len(studentAnswer)])),\"i\")"}, {"name": "good_units", "description": "", "definition": "try(\ncompatible(quantity(1, student_units),correct_units),\nmsg,\nfeedback(msg);false)\n"}, {"name": "student_quantity", "description": "

This fixes the student answer for two common errors.  

\n

If student_units are wrong  - replace with correct units

\n

If student_scalar has the wrong sign - replace with right sign

\n

If student makes both errors, only one gets fixed.

", "definition": "switch(not good_units, \n student_scalar * correct_units, \n not right_sign,\n -quantity(student_scalar, student_units),\n quantity(student_scalar,student_units)\n)\n \n"}, {"name": "percent_error", "description": "", "definition": "try(\nscalar(abs((correct_quantity - student_quantity)/correct_quantity))*100 \n,msg,\nif(student_quantity=correct_quantity,0,100))\n "}, {"name": "right", "description": "", "definition": "percent_error <= settings['right']\n"}, {"name": "close", "description": "

Only marked close if the student actually has the right sign.

", "definition": "right_sign and percent_error <= settings['close']"}, {"name": "right_sign", "description": "", "definition": "sign(student_scalar) = sign(correct_quantity) "}], "settings": [{"name": "correctAnswer", "label": "Correct Quantity.", "help_url": "", "hint": "The correct answer given as a JME quantity.", "input_type": "code", "default_value": "", "evaluate": true}, {"name": "right", "label": "% Accuracy for right.", "help_url": "", "hint": "Question will be considered correct if the scalar part of the student's answer is within this % of correct value.", "input_type": "code", "default_value": "0.2", "evaluate": true}, {"name": "close", "label": "% Accuracy for close.", "help_url": "", "hint": "Question will be considered close if the scalar part of the student's answer is within this % of correct value.", "input_type": "code", "default_value": "1.0", "evaluate": true}, {"name": "C1", "label": "Close with units.", "help_url": "", "hint": "Partial Credit for close value with appropriate units.  if correct answer is 100 N and close is ±1%,
99  N is accepted.", "input_type": "percent", "default_value": "75"}, {"name": "C2", "label": "No units or wrong sign", "help_url": "", "hint": "Partial credit for forgetting units or using wrong sign.
If the correct answer is 100 N, both 100 and -100 N are accepted.", "input_type": "percent", "default_value": "50"}, {"name": "C3", "label": "Close, no units.", "help_url": "", "hint": "Partial Credit for close value but forgotten units.
This value would be close if the expected units were provided.  If the correct answer is 100 N, and close is ±1%,
99 is accepted.", "input_type": "percent", "default_value": "25"}], "public_availability": "always", "published": true, "extensions": ["quantities"]}], "resources": [["question-resources/Hunting.png", "bf98c400af0307d1de288d6b0c9a65ca6732644673cd504cede6ffc393279212.png"], ["question-resources/Hunting_DssPbOU.png", "4e17907ac288c612296bba275d8c28f251f56cdb0bfb728c15e158574588493c.png"]], "navigation": {"allowregen": true, "showfrontpage": false, "preventleave": false, "typeendtoleave": false}, "feedback": {"showactualmarkwhen": "always", "showtotalmarkwhen": "always", "showanswerstatewhen": "always", "showpartfeedbackmessageswhen": "always", "allowrevealanswer": true, "showexpectedanswerswhen": "inreview", "showadvicewhen": "inreview"}, "question_groups": [{"pickingStrategy": "all-ordered", "questions": [{"name": "Hunting #1 w/ units", "tags": [], "metadata": {"description": "

Hunting oscillation as a result of wheel conicity.

Combine first order ODEs into a second order ODE and solve.

", "licence": "Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International"}, "statement": "

The conicity of the wheels that enables steering around curve also serves to correct misalignment on straight track, resulting in an oscillation called hunting.

\n

For wheels with neutral diameter $D$ and conicity $c$, the relationship between transverse offset, $y$, and the angle of instantaneous direction of wheelset travel, $\\theta$, is given by:

\n

${d y \\over d t} = v \\sin(\\theta)$

\n

${d \\theta \\over d t} = - {2 \\omega c \\over L} y$

\n

where $v = \\omega D/2$ is the instantaneous linear velocity of the wheelset; the angular velocity, $\\omega$, is assumed to be constant.

\n

The track gauge, $L = 1.435$ m, is used as the separation of wheel-rail contacts.

\n

", "advice": "

A railway vehicle has wheels of diameter $\\var{diameter}$ m with conicity 1:$\\var{conicity}$. The wavelength (along the track) of the hunting motion can be estimated by setting $\\sin(\\theta) \\approx \\theta$ and combining the two first order differential equations into a second order differential equation:

\n

${d y \\over d t} = v \\sin(\\theta) \\approx v \\theta = {\\omega D \\over 2} \\theta$

\n

${d^2 y \\over d t^2} \\approx {\\omega D \\over 2} {d \\theta \\over d t} = - {\\omega D \\over 2} {2 \\omega c \\over L} y = - {\\omega^2 D c \\over L} y$

\n

which has general solution:

\n

$y=A\\cos\\left(\\omega t \\sqrt{D c \\over L}\\right) + B\\sin\\left(\\omega t \\sqrt{D c \\over L}\\right)$

\n

One oscillation corresponds to:

\n

$\\omega t \\sqrt{D c \\over L}=2 \\pi \\implies t = {2 \\pi \\over \\omega} \\sqrt{L \\over D c}$

\n

and the corresponding distance along the track, $\\lambda$, is therefore:

\n

$\\lambda = v t = {\\omega D \\over 2} t = \\pi \\sqrt{L D \\over c}$

\n

In this case,

\n

$\\lambda = \\pi \\sqrt{1.435 \\times \\var{diameter} \\times \\var{conicity}} = \\var{siground(wavelength,3)}$ m

", "rulesets": {}, "extensions": [], "builtin_constants": {"e": true, "pi,\u03c0": true, "i": true, "j": false}, "constants": [], "variables": {"diameter": {"name": "diameter", "group": "Ungrouped variables", "definition": "random(6..11)/10", "description": "

Wheel diameter [m].

", "templateType": "anything", "can_override": false}, "conicity": {"name": "conicity", "group": "Ungrouped variables", "definition": "random(2..6)*5", "description": "

Conicity [expressed as 1:conicity].

", "templateType": "anything", "can_override": false}, "wavelength": {"name": "wavelength", "group": "Ungrouped variables", "definition": "pi*sqrt(1.435*diameter*conicity)", "description": "

Wavelength of hunting motion [m].

", "templateType": "anything", "can_override": false}}, "variablesTest": {"condition": "", "maxRuns": 100}, "ungrouped_variables": ["diameter", "conicity", "wavelength"], "variable_groups": [], "functions": {}, "preamble": {"js": "", "css": ""}, "parts": [{"type": "gapfill", "useCustomName": true, "customName": "Wavelength", "marks": 0, "scripts": {}, "customMarkingAlgorithm": "", "extendBaseMarkingAlgorithm": true, "unitTests": [], "showCorrectAnswer": true, "showFeedbackIcon": true, "variableReplacements": [], "variableReplacementStrategy": "originalfirst", "nextParts": [], "suggestGoingBack": false, "adaptiveMarkingPenalty": 0, "exploreObjective": null, "prompt": "

A railway vehicle has wheels of diameter $\\var{diameter}$ m with conicity 1:$\\var{conicity}$. The wavelength (along the track) of the hunting motion is: [[0]]

", "gaps": [{"type": "engineering-answer", "useCustomName": true, "customName": "Wavelength", "marks": "4", "scripts": {}, "customMarkingAlgorithm": "", "extendBaseMarkingAlgorithm": true, "unitTests": [], "showCorrectAnswer": true, "showFeedbackIcon": true, "variableReplacements": [], "variableReplacementStrategy": "originalfirst", "nextParts": [], "suggestGoingBack": false, "adaptiveMarkingPenalty": 0, "exploreObjective": null, "settings": {"correctAnswer": "quantity(wavelength,\"m\")", "right": "0.2", "close": "1.0", "C1": "75", "C2": "50", "C3": "25"}}], "sortAnswers": false}], "partsMode": "all", "maxMarks": 0, "objectives": [], "penalties": [], "objectiveVisibility": "always", "penaltyVisibility": "always", "contributors": [{"name": "Francis Franklin", "profile_url": "https://numbas.mathcentre.ac.uk/accounts/profile/1887/"}], "resources": ["question-resources/Hunting.png", "question-resources/Hunting_DssPbOU.png"]}]}], "contributors": [{"name": "Francis Franklin", "profile_url": "https://numbas.mathcentre.ac.uk/accounts/profile/1887/"}]}