// Numbas version: finer_feedback_settings {"name": "Hunting #2 w/ units", "extensions": ["quantities"], "custom_part_types": [{"source": {"pk": 19, "author": {"name": "William Haynes", "pk": 2530}, "edit_page": "/part_type/19/edit"}, "name": "Engineering Accuracy with units", "short_name": "engineering-answer", "description": "
A value with units marked right if within an adjustable % error of the correct value. Marked close if within a wider margin of error.
", "help_url": "", "input_widget": "string", "input_options": {"correctAnswer": "siground(settings['correctAnswer'],4)", "hint": {"static": true, "value": ""}, "allowEmpty": {"static": true, "value": true}}, "can_be_gap": true, "can_be_step": true, "marking_script": "mark:\nswitch( \n right and good_units and right_sign, add_credit(1.0,'Correct.'),\n right and good_units and not right_sign, add_credit(settings['C2'],'Wrong sign.'),\n right and right_sign and not good_units, add_credit(settings['C2'],'Correct value, but wrong or missing units.'),\n close and good_units, add_credit(settings['C1'],'Close.'),\n close and not good_units, add_credit(settings['C3'],'Answer is close, but wrong or missing units.'),\n incorrect('Wrong answer.')\n)\n\ninterpreted_answer:\nqty(student_scalar, student_units)\n\n\n\ncorrect_quantity:\nsettings[\"correctAnswer\"]\n\n\n\ncorrect_units:\nunits(correct_quantity)\n\n\nallowed_notation_styles:\n[\"plain\",\"en\"]\n\nmatch_student_number:\nmatchnumber(studentAnswer,allowed_notation_styles)\n\nstudent_scalar:\nmatch_student_number[1]\n\nstudent_units:\nreplace_regex('ohms','ohm',\n replace_regex('\u00b0', ' deg',\n replace_regex('-', ' ' ,\n studentAnswer[len(match_student_number[0])..len(studentAnswer)])),\"i\")\n\ngood_units:\ntry(\ncompatible(quantity(1, student_units),correct_units),\nmsg,\nfeedback(msg);false)\n\n\nstudent_quantity:\nswitch(not good_units, \n student_scalar * correct_units, \n not right_sign,\n -quantity(student_scalar, student_units),\n quantity(student_scalar,student_units)\n)\n \n\n\npercent_error:\ntry(\nscalar(abs((correct_quantity - student_quantity)/correct_quantity))*100 \n,msg,\nif(student_quantity=correct_quantity,0,100))\n \n\nright:\npercent_error <= settings['right']\n\n\nclose:\nright_sign and percent_error <= settings['close']\n\nright_sign:\nsign(student_scalar) = sign(correct_quantity)", "marking_notes": [{"name": "mark", "description": "This is the main marking note. It should award credit and provide feedback based on the student's answer.", "definition": "switch( \n right and good_units and right_sign, add_credit(1.0,'Correct.'),\n right and good_units and not right_sign, add_credit(settings['C2'],'Wrong sign.'),\n right and right_sign and not good_units, add_credit(settings['C2'],'Correct value, but wrong or missing units.'),\n close and good_units, add_credit(settings['C1'],'Close.'),\n close and not good_units, add_credit(settings['C3'],'Answer is close, but wrong or missing units.'),\n incorrect('Wrong answer.')\n)"}, {"name": "interpreted_answer", "description": "A value representing the student's answer to this part.", "definition": "qty(student_scalar, student_units)\n\n"}, {"name": "correct_quantity", "description": "", "definition": "settings[\"correctAnswer\"]\n\n"}, {"name": "correct_units", "description": "", "definition": "units(correct_quantity)\n"}, {"name": "allowed_notation_styles", "description": "", "definition": "[\"plain\",\"en\"]"}, {"name": "match_student_number", "description": "", "definition": "matchnumber(studentAnswer,allowed_notation_styles)"}, {"name": "student_scalar", "description": "", "definition": "match_student_number[1]"}, {"name": "student_units", "description": "Modify the unit portion of the student's answer by
\n1. replacing \"ohms\" with \"ohm\" case insensitive
\n2. replacing '-' with ' '
\n3. replacing '°' with ' deg'
\nto allow answers like 10 ft-lb and 30°
", "definition": "replace_regex('ohms','ohm',\n replace_regex('\u00b0', ' deg',\n replace_regex('-', ' ' ,\n studentAnswer[len(match_student_number[0])..len(studentAnswer)])),\"i\")"}, {"name": "good_units", "description": "", "definition": "try(\ncompatible(quantity(1, student_units),correct_units),\nmsg,\nfeedback(msg);false)\n"}, {"name": "student_quantity", "description": "This fixes the student answer for two common errors.
\nIf student_units are wrong - replace with correct units
\nIf student_scalar has the wrong sign - replace with right sign
\nIf student makes both errors, only one gets fixed.
", "definition": "switch(not good_units, \n student_scalar * correct_units, \n not right_sign,\n -quantity(student_scalar, student_units),\n quantity(student_scalar,student_units)\n)\n \n"}, {"name": "percent_error", "description": "", "definition": "try(\nscalar(abs((correct_quantity - student_quantity)/correct_quantity))*100 \n,msg,\nif(student_quantity=correct_quantity,0,100))\n "}, {"name": "right", "description": "", "definition": "percent_error <= settings['right']\n"}, {"name": "close", "description": "Only marked close if the student actually has the right sign.
", "definition": "right_sign and percent_error <= settings['close']"}, {"name": "right_sign", "description": "", "definition": "sign(student_scalar) = sign(correct_quantity) "}], "settings": [{"name": "correctAnswer", "label": "Correct Quantity.", "help_url": "", "hint": "The correct answer given as a JME quantity.", "input_type": "code", "default_value": "", "evaluate": true}, {"name": "right", "label": "% Accuracy for right.", "help_url": "", "hint": "Question will be considered correct if the scalar part of the student's answer is within this % of correct value.", "input_type": "code", "default_value": "0.2", "evaluate": true}, {"name": "close", "label": "% Accuracy for close.", "help_url": "", "hint": "Question will be considered close if the scalar part of the student's answer is within this % of correct value.", "input_type": "code", "default_value": "1.0", "evaluate": true}, {"name": "C1", "label": "Close with units.", "help_url": "", "hint": "Partial Credit for close value with appropriate units. if correct answer is 100 N and close is ±1%,Hunting oscillation as a result of wheel conicity.
Combine first order ODEs into a second order ODE and solve.
The conicity of the wheels that enables steering around curve also serves to correct misalignment on straight track, resulting in an oscillation called hunting.
\nFor wheels with neutral diameter $D$ and conicity $c$, the relationship between transverse offset, $y$, and the angle of instantaneous direction of wheelset travel, $\\theta$, is given by:
\n${d y \\over d t} = v \\sin(\\theta)$
\n${d \\theta \\over d t} = - {2 \\omega c \\over L} y$
\nwhere $v = \\omega D/2$ is the instantaneous linear velocity of the wheelset; the angular velocity, $\\omega$, is assumed to be constant.
\nThe track gauge, $L = 1.435$ m, is used as the separation of wheel-rail contacts.
\n
A railway vehicle has wheels of diameter $\\var{diameter}$ m with conicity 1:$\\var{conicity}$. On straight track with velocity $v_\\text{[km/h]}=\\var{velocity}$ km/h, the period (in time) of the hunting motion can be estimated by setting $\\sin(\\theta) \\approx \\theta$ and combining the two first order differential equations into a second order differential equation:
\n${d y \\over d t} = v \\sin(\\theta) \\approx v \\theta = {\\omega D \\over 2} \\theta$
\n${d^2 y \\over d t^2} \\approx {\\omega D \\over 2} {d \\theta \\over d t} = - {\\omega D \\over 2} {2 \\omega c \\over L} y = - {\\omega^2 D c \\over L} y$
\nwhich has general solution:
\n$y=A\\cos\\left(\\omega t \\sqrt{D c \\over L}\\right) + B\\sin\\left(\\omega t \\sqrt{D c \\over L}\\right)$
\nOne oscillation corresponds to:
\n$\\omega t \\sqrt{D c \\over L}=2 \\pi \\implies t = {2 \\pi \\over \\omega} \\sqrt{L \\over D c}$
\nIn this case, the period is:
\n$t = {2 \\pi \\over \\omega} \\sqrt{L \\over D c} = {\\pi \\over v} \\sqrt{L D \\over c} = {\\pi \\over \\var{velocity}/3.6} \\sqrt{1.435 \\times \\var{diameter} \\times \\var{conicity}} = \\var{siground(period,3)}$ s
\nso the frequency, $f$, is:
\n$f = {1 \\over t} = \\var{siground(frequency,3)}$ Hz
", "rulesets": {}, "extensions": [], "builtin_constants": {"e": true, "pi,\u03c0": true, "i": true, "j": false}, "constants": [], "variables": {"diameter": {"name": "diameter", "group": "Ungrouped variables", "definition": "random(6..11)/10", "description": "Wheel diameter [m].
", "templateType": "anything", "can_override": false}, "conicity": {"name": "conicity", "group": "Ungrouped variables", "definition": "random(2..6)*5", "description": "Conicity [expressed as 1:conicity].
", "templateType": "anything", "can_override": false}, "period": {"name": "period", "group": "Ungrouped variables", "definition": "pi*sqrt(1.435*diameter*conicity)*3.6/velocity", "description": "Period of hunting motion [s].
", "templateType": "anything", "can_override": false}, "velocity": {"name": "velocity", "group": "Ungrouped variables", "definition": "random(10..35)*10", "description": "Velocity [km/h].
", "templateType": "anything", "can_override": false}, "frequency": {"name": "frequency", "group": "Ungrouped variables", "definition": "1/period", "description": "Frequency of hunting motion [Hz].
", "templateType": "anything", "can_override": false}}, "variablesTest": {"condition": "", "maxRuns": 100}, "ungrouped_variables": ["diameter", "conicity", "velocity", "period", "frequency"], "variable_groups": [], "functions": {}, "preamble": {"js": "", "css": ""}, "parts": [{"type": "gapfill", "useCustomName": true, "customName": "Frequency", "marks": 0, "scripts": {}, "customMarkingAlgorithm": "", "extendBaseMarkingAlgorithm": true, "unitTests": [], "showCorrectAnswer": true, "showFeedbackIcon": true, "variableReplacements": [], "variableReplacementStrategy": "originalfirst", "nextParts": [], "suggestGoingBack": false, "adaptiveMarkingPenalty": 0, "exploreObjective": null, "prompt": "A railway vehicle has wheels of diameter $\\var{diameter}$ m with conicity 1:$\\var{conicity}$. On straight track with velocity $\\var{velocity}$ km/h, the frequency of the hunting motion is: [[0]]
", "gaps": [{"type": "engineering-answer", "useCustomName": true, "customName": "Frequency", "marks": "4", "scripts": {}, "customMarkingAlgorithm": "", "extendBaseMarkingAlgorithm": true, "unitTests": [], "showCorrectAnswer": true, "showFeedbackIcon": true, "variableReplacements": [], "variableReplacementStrategy": "originalfirst", "nextParts": [], "suggestGoingBack": false, "adaptiveMarkingPenalty": 0, "exploreObjective": null, "settings": {"correctAnswer": "quantity(frequency,\"Hz\")", "right": "0.2", "close": "1.0", "C1": "75", "C2": "50", "C3": "25"}}], "sortAnswers": false}], "partsMode": "all", "maxMarks": 0, "objectives": [], "penalties": [], "objectiveVisibility": "always", "penaltyVisibility": "always", "contributors": [{"name": "Francis Franklin", "profile_url": "https://numbas.mathcentre.ac.uk/accounts/profile/1887/"}], "resources": ["question-resources/Hunting.png", "question-resources/Hunting_DssPbOU.png"]}]}], "contributors": [{"name": "Francis Franklin", "profile_url": "https://numbas.mathcentre.ac.uk/accounts/profile/1887/"}]}