Christian Lawson-Perfect
Member of the e-learning unit in Newcastle University's School of Mathematics and Statistics.
Lead developer of Numbas.
I'm happy to answer any questions - email me.
Christian's activity
Christian Lawson-Perfect commented on Fraction multiplication 9 years, 4 months ago
This looks good, but part d seems vindictively hard! What's it assessing?
From the advice, it looks like:
- BODMAS - this isn't what the question's about
- Squaring fractions - have a smaller question on this earlier, e.g. "calculate $\left(\frac{a}{b}\right)^2$".
- Division of fractions - again, not what the question's about.
I reckon you could just delete part d, or spin it into a separate question.
Christian Lawson-Perfect on Solving linear inequalities 9 years, 4 months ago
Gave some feedback: Has some problems
Christian Lawson-Perfect commented on Solving linear inequalities 9 years, 4 months ago
Parts
Part e has "x<..." in the expected answer. It should just be a number.
In part f, I think you've forgotten the coefficient of $a$.
Advice
I've corrected "on it's own" to "on its own".
Why were there sometimes brackets around the numbers? I've removed them.
Part d: minus signs have gone missing in the second line. You say you've highlighted something in red, but I can't see it because I'm colourblind. Find a way to refer to things in text.
Something's gone wrong in part e: the right-hand $x$ term goes missing in the second line. And I wouldn't think of this as pulling out a factor of $x$ anyway: you're collecting like terms. The thrid line seems to be nonsense too.
Part f: I think the second line is supposed to have collected all the $x$ terms on the left, but the coefficient is wrong. And then I got a third line showing division by $15-5$. Why wouldn't you collect together first and just divide by $10$?
I dispute that it's easier to divide first in part $g$! I got an $h$ term and the advice says to divide by $2$ first. Maybe make sure that you're dividing by the gcd of all the coefficients, and the gcd is greater than 1.
Christian Lawson-Perfect on Inverse and composite functions 9 years, 4 months ago
Gave some feedback: Has some problems
Christian Lawson-Perfect commented on Inverse and composite functions 9 years, 4 months ago
Use \left( and \right) around fractions to make sure the brackets stretch to the correct height.
In the advice for the final part, I would use an identity symbol ($\equiv$), and maybe preface the identity with "it is always true that"
Christian Lawson-Perfect on Square and cube numbers 9 years, 4 months ago
Gave some feedback: Has some problems
Christian Lawson-Perfect commented on Square and cube numbers 9 years, 4 months ago
I don't think part a is a well-conceived question. First of all, I don't like telling students not to use calculators. You can sometimes hint that a calculator won't be useful, but don't give them the idea that using calculator is ever bad.
When you're told $x$ and $x^3$ but not $x^2$ - why would you ever calculate $(x^3)^{2/3}$ instead of just squaring $x$?
Similarly, when you're given $x^3$ and $x^3$ but not $x$, I don't think anyone would take the cube root instead of the square root. So why show both?
Some ideas for different questions on the same topic:
- Calculate $x^2$ for $x$ from 1 to 10.
- Calculate $x^3$ for $x$ from 1 to 10.
- Find a number such that $x^2 \gt 100$ and $x^2 \lt 120$.
- An "always/sometimes/never" question for some statements. The student has to say if each of the statements is always true, sometimes true, or never true.
- $x^3$ is greater than $x^2$. (sometimes)
- If $x$ is negative, $x^2$ is negative (never)
- If $x$ is negative, $x^3$ is negative (always)
- $x^2 = x$ (sometimes)
- $(x+1)^2 \gt x$ (sometimes)
- $(x+1)^3 \gt x$ (always)
- When $x$ is a whole number, $x^2$ divides $x^3$ (always)
- $x^3$ has the opposite sign to $x$ (never)
Part b is good - it could be a separate question, called "calculate powers of ten"
Christian Lawson-Perfect on Using the Quadratic Formula to Solve Equations of the Form $ax^2 +bx+c=0$ 9 years, 4 months ago
Gave some feedback: Has some problems
Christian Lawson-Perfect commented on Using the Quadratic Formula to Solve Equations of the Form $ax^2 +bx+c=0$ 9 years, 4 months ago
The non-zero right-hand sides in part a are gotchas: I'd like to have a nice part first, where the right-hand side is zero.
Could you make the coefficients in part b work so that you get integers out? You want to see if the student can work out how to deal with getting an algebraic answer, and rounding errors would be a distraction.
In part b it looks like the roots are the wrong way round - the lowest root is second.
You could split this into two questions: "use the quadratic formula to solve an equation with non-zero RHS", and "use the quadratic formula to solve an equation in terms of another variable".
Christian Lawson-Perfect on Expansion of brackets 9 years, 4 months ago
Gave some feedback: Has some problems